Why Hotel Key Cards Stop Working & How to Fix It

The Scenario Every General Manager Dreads - And Every Guest Hates

A guest arrives late, exhausted, and drags their heavy luggage down a long corridor to Room 314. They slide their key card, wait for the green light, and... nothing. Just a blinking red error. They try again. Red light.

Then comes the "Walk of Shame"—the frustrating trudge back to the lobby to tell the front desk, "My key doesn't work."

While often blamed on "user error," the reality is that hotel key cards are technical tools with physical limitations. For hotel operators, understanding why do hotel key cards stop working is the first step to reducing front desk complaints. In this guide, we break down the science of magstripe vs RFID key cards, debunk the myths about cell phones, and explain how proper hotel key card envelopes can save your staff time and your guests frustration.

The difference Between Low Coercivity And High Coercivity Key Cards And Locks

To fix the problem, you have to understand the technology. Not all plastic hotel key cards are built the same. If you are ordering replacements, you must match the "Coercivity" (magnetic strength) to your specific hotel lock systems.

1. Generic "LoCo" (Low Coercivity) Key Cards

The Look: These typically have a brown magnetic stripe.

The Tech: "LoCo" cards are encoded at a lower energy level (about 300 Oersteds).

The Use: This is the industry standard for legacy hotel locks (like older Onity, Tesa, or Ilco systems). They are cost-effective and easy to rewrite, but because they are "low energy," they are susceptible to being erased by stray magnetic fields.

2. HiCo (High Coercivity) Key Cards

The Look: These typically have a black magnetic stripe.

The Tech: Encoded at high energy (2750 Oersteds), similar to a bank credit card.

The Use: They are durable and hard to erase, but most hotel front desk encoders are not powerful enough to write to them.

3. RFID Hotel Key Cards (Mifare 1K)

The Upgrade: If you want to eliminate demagnetization entirely, the answer is RFID hotel key cards. Instead of a stripe, these use a contactless chip (often Mifare 1K) to communicate with the lock. They are waterproof, durable, and immune to magnets.

"Low Coercivity" Hotel Key Cards

Generic "Low Coercivity" hotel key cards are easily programmable and ready for use. This key card features a low coercivity (LoCo) magnetic strip that provides your guests with an easy way to access entry into their specified hotel room by entering and removing or swiping the card through the port or slot on the hotel door lock. Plastic cards are litho-printed on a PVC card with a standard "Welcome, Please Enjoy Your Stay" message on the from and a helpful "Operating Instructions" images on the back. Cards are laminated for long lasting service and fit standard key kard envelopes.

 

Using Generic Key Cards For Your Electronic Lock System

A common misconception is that you must buy expensive, branded cards directly from the lock manufacturer. However, you can use generic hotel key cards. Your lock system reads the data on the track or chip; it does not scan the hotel logo printed on the plastic. Switching to generics can save your property 30%–50% in supply costs.

How to Program Instructions: Whether you use custom branded key cards or generic white ones, the programming workflow remains identical:

 

For Magstripe Cards:

• Insert the card into your front desk encoder.
• In your PMS, select "New Key," enter the Room Number and Number of Nights.
• Click "Make Key" and the encoder will swipe the card to write the data to Track 3.

For RFID Cards:

• Place the card on the encoder pad (no swiping required).
• The system sends a wireless signal to the chip, assigning the encrypted "handshake" for that specific room.

Pro Tip: While generics work for 90% of systems (Onity, Ilco, Saflok), always check if your specific system uses proprietary encryption (like some newer VingCard systems) before buying in bulk.

Hotel RFID Key Cards

Premium hotel RFID key cards are ready for programming and use. These RFID key cards are manufactured to meet or exceed original manufacturers specifications. RFID top quality mifare 1K compatible chip cards are as reliable as they are superior. Plastic cards are litho-printed on a PVC card with a standard "Welcome, Please Enjoy Your Stay" message on the from and a helpful "Please Return Card" message on the back. Cards are laminated for long lasting service and fit standard key kard envelopes.

 

The Verdict: Why Do Hotel Key Cards Stop Working? Magstripe vs RFID

Do cell phones really erase hotel key cards? This is the #1 question guests ask at the front desk.

If you use LoCo Magstripe Cards: YES. The speaker magnet in a modern smartphone (and the MagSafe ring on the back) is strong enough to scramble the data on a Low Coercivity card. If a guest puts their key and phone in the same pocket, the key will likely fail.

If you use RFID Cards: NO. Radio frequency chips are immune to magnetic fields. A guest can tape an RFID card to their phone, and it will still work perfectly.

How to Protect Them: If you haven't upgraded to RFID yet, you must educate your guests. This is where hotel key card holders become a vital operational tool. A simple paper folder acts as a physical barrier, encouraging the guest to keep the card in a wallet or purse rather than pressed against their iPhone.

What information should be on a key card envelope?

Hotel key card envelopes are not just protective covers; they are prime key card marketing real estate. Since the guest looks at this envelope every time they enter their room, use it to answer FAQs and drive revenue. There is a standard form for most printed key card envelopes. 

Recommended standard layout for maximum utility:

• Room Number: Crucial Safety Tip—Never write the room number on the key card itself! If lost, it is a security breach. Write it on the envelope only.
• Wi-Fi Password: Stop the calls to the front desk by printing the network and password clearly.
• Checkout Time: A subtle reminder that helps housekeeping turn rooms faster.
• QR Codes: Link to your room service menu, digital concierge, or review site.
• Custom Message or Symbol: A "Thank you for not smoking" message or a no smoking symbol would be good examples to include to utilize of any extra space, if space allows.

Hotel Key Card Envelopes

Stock up today on this essential item. These key card envelopes are made of a high quality premium 100g paper stock with thumb-cut style to easily pull outa key card. It holds and protects up to two key cards and provides an area to write the room number on the front above the "Welcome, Enjoy Your Stay" message. Pre-printed information on the back highlights general safety rules for your guests.

 

Conclusion

The "Walk of Shame" doesn't have to be a daily occurrence at your property. By understanding the difference between magstripe vs RFID key cards and investing in high-quality custom hotel key cards, you ensure that the first impression—opening the door—is a smooth one.

Whether you need hotel key card prprogramming for essential function, eco-friendly key cards to meet sustainability goals, or reliable generic stock key card envelopes to save budget, National Hospitality has the exact items necessary to keep your access control running smoothly.

Shop our full selection of key cards & envelopes at National Hospitality Supply and stop the lockouts before they start.

Where To Buy

Go to the Key Cards & Envelopes page and add your items to the shopping cart.

Account Setup and Registration takes only a few minutes when registering your account.

• For more information, visit www.nathosp.com
• To speak with a representative, call 1-800-526-8224 (8AM - 6PM CST)
• To email customer service, send a message to cs@nathosp.com